{ feuilleton }

1. #1 posted by bluewyvern

   

   Mar 15th, 2009

   Congratulations on your beautiful acquisition. I would love to get my hands on a nice illustrated set of Arabian Nights (antique/rare status not required), but I haven’t found anything that looks right. I’m a completist, so no selections or abridgments for me — but of course finding the “real” or “complete” edition is no simple matter.

2. #2 posted by Nathalie (Spacedlaw)

   

   Mar 15th, 2009

   Wonderful. Were you lucky enough to get all three or was this just a stray?

3. #3 posted by mr.kenneth

   

   Mar 15th, 2009

   luvverly!

   and the marbling looks gorgeous!

4. #4 posted by John

   

   Mar 15th, 2009

   Bluewyvern: the translations by Sir Richard Burton used to be the ones to get but there have been many others since, of course. Burton’s collection is ten volumes to Lane’s three and Burton’s pioneering interest in sex and the Arab world mean that he didn’t censor anything unlike Lane and others. There’s a PDF version available.

   Nathalie: this was a lone volume, unfortunately. The illustrations are so profuse–and quite odd in places–I wouldn’t mind having a full set.

5. #5 posted by John

   

   Mar 15th, 2009

   Burton was never a man to mince words and he gives us his appraisal of the Lane edition in the introduction to his own translation. This goes some way to telling you why Burton’s version of the stories has been held in such high regard; he looked at the competition and found it wanting.

   That amiable and devoted Arabist, the late Edward William Lane does not score a success in his “New Translation of the Tales of a Thousand and One Nights” (London: Charles Knight and Co., MDCCCXXXIX.) of which there have been four English editions, besides American, two edited by E. S. Poole. He chose the abbreviating Bulak Edition; and, of its two hundred tales, he has omitted about half and by far the more characteristic half: the work was intended for “the drawing-room table;” and, consequently, the workman was compelled to avoid the “objectionable” and aught “approaching to licentiousness.” He converts the Arabian Nights into the Arabian Chapters, arbitrarily changing the division and, worse still, he converts some chapters into notes. He renders poetry by prose and apologises for not omitting it altogether: he neglects assonance and he is at once too Oriental and not Oriental enough. He had small store of Arabic at the time–Lane of the Nights is not Lane of the Dictionary–and his pages are disfigured by many childish mistakes. Worst of all, the three handsome volumes are rendered unreadable as Sale’s Koran by their anglicised Latin, their sesquipedalian un-English words, and the stiff and stilted style of half a century ago when our prose was, perhaps, the worst in Europe. Their cargo of Moslem learning was most valuable to the student, but utterly out of place for readers of “The Nights;” re-published, as these notes have been separately (London, Chatto, 1883), they are an ethnological text-book.

6. #6 posted by Miss L

   

   Sep 18th, 2009

   Hi there,
   I’ve come across Volume I of EW Lane’s Arabian Nights (1850) in a Charity Shop. I am still considering whether to buy it or not (it’s not cheap and the first few pages are torn). Is it worth acquiring? Grateful for advice.

7. #7 posted by John

   

   Sep 18th, 2009

   Hi Miss L. I’m not a book dealer. If you want to know the going rate of a book I’d advise browsing Abebooks.

8. #8 posted by Linda

   

   Oct 9th, 2009

   I have 1 through 4 volumes of The Arabian Nighs Entertainments. Published by Hearsts Copyright 1914. Not illistrated. In very good shape.These books are called ‘the new national edition’. If anyone knows anything about them or if they are worth anything, please let me know

Leave a comment for ‘Edward William Lane’s Arabian Nights Entertainments’